ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Keynes and Schumpeter: Swimming against the stream in unison; separately seeking new shores
Author: KURZ Heinz D.


The paper discusses the relationship between Keynes and Schumpeter. The attention focuses on (i) their “visions” of the economic process; (ii) the statements they published about each other; (iii) their disenchantment with conventional economic analysis; and (iv) similarities and differences of their theories. It is argued that notwithstanding Schumpeter’s acerbic criticism of Keynes, the two authors shared important convictions that united them and opposed them to the mainstream. Both were intellectual “entrepreneurs” concerned with creative destruction. They rejected inter alia the received view of money as a veil and saw the real and the monetary side of the economy as intimately intertwined. They also refuted the conventional view of the role of savings as the key to prosperity and emphasized instead the role of investment and innovations. Characterising Keynes’ view as short run, monetary and demand-driven, and Schumpeter’s as long run, real and supply-driven provides at best a first approximation to their analyses. Looking closer reveals that things are invariably more complicated. Both analyses exhibit important strengths and shortcomings. When investment is given priority over saving, then the principle of effective demand can hardly be rejected, and when the long run is at stake, then innovations have to be attributed a major role. In view of the heretic elements in Keynes and Schumpeter’s theories, it comes as a surprise that they would unswervingly stick to the Marshallian and Walrasian variants of the marginalist theory as points of orientation of their own work. One might comment on this in the following way: it would be too much to expect from a scientist to anticipate all the implications of his or her innovation, as it would be too much to expect from an entrepreneur to anticipate all the implications for the market, he or she is about to revolutionise.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.