ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Thornton versus Ricardo: Two Alternative Perspectives on Money and Trade
Author: Weber Isabella Maria


Hicks (1967) identifies Henry Thornton’s “An Enquiry into the Nature of the Paper Credit of Great Britain” and David Ricardo’s “The High Price of Bullion” as the foundational texts of “two strands of classical economics” (p. 167) with regard to their view on money. This paper aims to build on and transcend beyond Hicks in linking Thornton’s and Ricardo’s theories of money both to their respective views on the ‘natural’ state of society and their theories of trade. Ricardo suggests a natural state of barter where production is supplied for immediate consumption and thereby creates its own demand. Metallic money helps to make exchanges less costly that would have happened anyways. The value of metallic money is equalized internationally by the export of money to those countries where it is relatively dear. Such exports do not imply unfavourable trade. Paper money shall work in the same way as metallic money. This can be guaranteed by convertibility. If, however, more paper money is issued than would have circulated in terms of metallic money it leads to inflation and the result is trade that is in fact unfavourable. Thornton on the other hand envisions the barter economy itself as a monetary economy in the sense that it must already be built on credit relations necessary to facilitate exchange. There can be no commerce without credit relations. There can be no exchange economy without money. Hence, for Thornton money cannot be too scarce or too abundant relative to some objective standard. If trade is imbalanced it is the result of shocks to the real economy and not of monetary policy. Instead, trade imbalances can be overcome by expanding the quantity of money to promote the productive forces of the economy. In sum, Ricardo lays the foundations for both monetary orthodoxy and orthodox trade theory. As long as banks do not over-issue money, free trade can only be beneficial for any country. Only if banks not bound to the rule of convertibility over-issue money, exchange becomes unfavourable while inflation can only do harm and no good. In contrast, Thornton prefigures countercyclical monetary policy, the rejection of Say’s Law and the possibility of persistent unfavourable free trade. A country can engage in unfavourable trade out of necessity. In such a situation, expansionary monetary policy can help to revive the domestic forces of production. If an economy has permanently inferior productive forces, it might engage permanently in unfavourable trade, which must result in high levels of foreign debt, persistent global imbalances and debt crisis. Both Ricardo’s and Thornton’s views on money and trade are alive in the debate on the present crisis. They still provide us with two alternative strands to think both about the causes as well as the cures of trade imbalances and financial crisis.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.