ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Pufendorf on Equality and Inequality
Author: Saether Arild


Abstract Samuel Pufendorf presented his natural law theories, which also included his views on equality and inequality among men in all his natural law works, but particularly in his major work De Jure Naturae et Gentium (The Law of Nature and Nations) in eight books published in Lund, Sweden in 1672. He was an eclectic that in his natural law, builds on the Greeks, the Romans, the Bible, the Koran, the 14th and 15th century scholars as well as the more recent ones, when he developed his own theories. In the 1688 edition, he has the names of 400 authors on the reference list. Authors that he quotes and uses to drive home his points. Pufendorf’s natural law is deduced from reason and founded on the condition of man. In a chapter entitled All men are accounted as naturally equal, he starts out by establishing that a man should hold every other man his natural equal. Pufendorf stresses that the greatest inequality results from a civil state. Using the natural law precept on equality he discusses several issues that were important in his time. One of the issues is the inequality among men caused by slavery. His opinion is clear slavery is against natural law. Another issue is the inequality between man and wife. Again by nature all individuals have equal rights. Marriage should be by contract, but this does not mean that a husband does not have sovereignty over the wife. Here the question is raised if Pufendorf knew about the emerging feminist philosophy. He discusses how property should be divided among mankind on the basis of equality. However, private property arose from the imposition of men and is therefore not based on natural law. It is founded on pacts. Private property, which leads to inequality, was progressively introduced when men, under pressure of growing population and depleted resources moved from one stage of development to the next. Stage of gathering and hunting was replaced by one on herding of animals on pasture land. Discovery of grain led to cultivation and an agricultural society. Pufendorf develops a theory of exchange, value and money in the fourth stage, a commercial society. Inequality between rulers and the ruled develops when states were established by two pacts and one decree. Pufendorf discusses supreme sovereignty in three forms of government, democracy, aristocracy and absolute monarchy. Inequality arise when the authority delegates to certain citizen the exercise of some special authority over the rest, or to some special privilege granted by the sovereignty. It is clear, although carefully formulated, that he does not believe in nobility by birth. The financial systems, including taxations, in most the European states in the 17th century where fundamentally unjust and corrupt. Pufendorf outlines the foundation for a just and equal system, including budget discipline. His tax collection rules are modern by today’s standards. He wanted proportional taxes on incomes for all, but with only symbolic tax for the poor. However, he preferred consumption taxes and import levies on luxuries. Pufendorf’s natural law, including his views and equality and inequality, was dispersed across Europe For more than 100 years, he was the most read scholar in Europe and North America. This paper claims that Pufendorf’s doctrines were used and became amalgamated with the ideas of the most important scholars across Europe such as John Locke, Charles Montesquieu, Jean Jacques Rousseau, Francis Hutcheson and Adam Smith.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.