ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The true and false rights of Rueff: from a monetary disequilibrium theory to a social disorder theory
Author: DAOU Marie
Jacques Rueff is a French economist of 20th century who is known for his stance on the monetary debates (in particular concerning the financial and economic equilibrium) during the inter-war period and after the Second World War. Between these two periods, Rueff has written a book: L’Ordre social (1945). This one seems to be a breaking point in his intellectual project; in particular, because he changes his scale of analysis, moving from the economic balance and the monetary stability to the study of man and society. In this book, Rueff underlines that the stability of the social system rests on the property rights which are thus laid at the heart of his “theory of true and false rights”; a theory, by the way, which has not truly been discussed by the secondary literature. Our paper aims precisely to remedy at this gap and resumes thus the Rueffian theorization of these notions, while offering an analytical framework helping to better understand Rueff’s theory. But then, how to explain this shift in Rueff’s thought. According to us, this tipping point is linked to the historical context. Indeed, the writing period of L’Ordre social is characterized by a very great monetary and financial disorder but also the rise of totalitarianism, and then the war. In light of this context, Rueff searches the causes of these dictatorial regimes, and blames the role of the monetary and economic instability in their emergence. As a result of that, Rueff reaffirms his priority of defending the man freedom, and explains how these financial and monetary disorders have disturbed the social order and undermined the basics of freedom. Here, the shift in his thought begins. Indeed, in his 1945 book, he leaves aside the purely economic notions and rethinks them in a more general framework: the social order. Thus, we think that the purpose of his book is not only to explain the causes of the social disorder, but it also is mainly to attempt of rebuilding a social order which would, above all, be liberal (i.e. a social order whose the main goal would be the preservation of the freedom). It should be pointed out that Rueff doesn’t define the concept of freedom in 1945, but this notion refers directly to the concept of property rights, with the idea that man is free as long as he can exercise sovereignty over his rights (in other words, as long as the basics of the social order (i.e. the property rights) are preserved). Nevertheless, all the specific aspect of Rueff’s thought is that the property rights can be “false rights” and it is precisely which worries Rueff. Indeed, he specifies that if the “false rights” are in excessive quantities, the freedom and the social order are directly threatened. Rueff identifies this situation when there is a financial disequilibrium (such as in an inflation regime). He is even more precise, and specifies that the State is the main responsible for these imbalances (via its public deficits). As a result, Rueff’s aim is to preserve the financial equilibrium of government (i.e. the balanced budget) in order to avoid inflation and thus totalitarianism. This project materializes by “the theory of true and false rights”, which shows according to us, that this is from the financial and monetary disequilibrium, that the social disorders are born, and that freedom is threatened. This theory involves two aspects: first, it emphasizes on the features and causes of these plagues (namely inflation and the dictatorial regimes); second, it allows a glimpse of remedies in order to fight against their development.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)