ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Karl Polanyi and the Global Inequality Thesis
Author: Ozcelik Emre, Ozveren Eyup


The recent resurgence of inequality as a major concern for economists has not yet had its repercussions in a similar rise in the number and quality of works that look to the international picture. The latter has had a long but marginalized legacy. No matter how critical Adam Smith was of mercantilists, he inherited from them the conception of a competition for wealth and power among the states and/or nations as the fundamental concern of political economy, a fact attested by his choice of title for his Wealth of Nations. Moreover, he identified an inevitable state of inequality for the then present and the foreseeable future but a probable ultimate convergence due to the elimination of differences of ‘civilization’ and military power thanks to the peaceful effects of free trade. The shift of focus of political economy from Smith’s ‘nations’ in the plural to ‘nation’ in the singular pushed this proto-thesis to the sidelines. The bases of what we call ‘global inequality thesis’ are the empirical findings of Raul Prebisch and Hans Singer, Marxian theory of value, and the concept of uneven development. Without the first, the latter could not have produced the somewhat ground-shifting effect that came along with Structuralist and Dependency schools. Be that as it may, these otherwise diverse foundations join forces in ascribing the very source of this inequality to economic factors. We will elaborate this discussion in the first part of our paper. In the rest of the paper, our contention will be that Karl Polanyi’s The Great Transformation provides a strong basis for the study of global inequality thesis from an institutionalist point of view. The political-economy aspect of Polanyi’s work has been well taken by heterodox economists who nevertheless continue to work on the nation-state as a unit of analysis. Polanyi himself was also first and foremost interested in the study of national cases, starting with the British model, but he was well aware that its lagged replications were placed in a global context. We wish to work out the implications of his book for the study of global inequality thesis that will nevertheless help transcend the shortcomings of previous critical approaches listed above that lay the ground for the existing literature. To this effect, Polanyi had three specific critiques of: i) the economistic treatment of ‘social costs’ as exploitation, ii) the labor theory of value, and ii) the standard theory of international trade. We will spell out the important bearings of each critique in subsequent sections of the paper. We will wind up our discussion with an evaluation of Polanyi’s ‘global institutionalism’ with a specific emphasis on its implications for the study of global inequality. We will also suggest what openings this may bring to the studies of ‘local’, that is nation-state or regional inequality.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.