ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Guicciardini and Economic Inequalities
Author: Regent Nikola
The paper analyses the discussion of economic inequalities in the writings of Francesco Guicciardini. For a sixteenth-century political thinker (and historian), Guicciardini demonstrates a remarkable level of interest in economic issues. Most prominent is his La Decima scalata, the first treatise ever written on progressive taxation; however, his other writings, particularly those on organising the government in Florence, show a particular interest in the question of economic (in)equality. Guicciardini was strongly influenced by the ancient authors which he studied, and in his early writings demonstrated a special attachment to the austere example of ancient Sparta. Wealth and luxury have a corrupting, damaging influence on human nature, and move men’s interest away from the pursuit of virtue. This disease should be cut out with “a knife of Lycurgus”, to renew the body politic, and install a Spartan-like equality of economic conditions, where in a frugal environment of equal, limited means, citizens can dedicate themselves to achieving virtue. Yet, even in his early years Guicciardini doubted the feasibility of such a reformation in Florence: in the prevailing political circumstances that was too pernicious a route. La Decima scalata, with its two discourses pro and contra the proposed tax, anticipates all the main arguments for and against progressive taxation. Guicciardini offers extremely nuanced argumentation for both positions. The paper pays special attention to what will be later called “equality of sacrifice”. Guicciardini clearly sides with the second, ‘proto-libertarian’ position, which defends the traditional stratified society in Florence: while citizens should enjoy political and legal equality, this should not extend in any way into the economic domain. If the Spartan solution is unavailable to a commonwealth, Guicciardini then prefers no redistribution whatsoever: in a corrupt world, wealth is a protection for a prominent man, who can try to pursue virtue on the individual level. All the other, redistributive solutions in a commonwealth, which may be seen as being “in between” the two extremes, are worse options. But Guicciardini’s goal is promoting conditions conductive to pursuit of virtue – rather than equality per se (or the advancement of population’s material conditions). This is in line with his ancient sources – but in sharp contrast with more modern egalitarian theories. The paper emphasises the significance of reached insights for understanding the ideal of (economic) equality in the history of economic and political thought.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)