ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Robert Solow as an anti-Walrasian economist
Author: Ballandonne Matthieu, Rubin Goulven
Milton Friedman’s opposition to Walras and the Walrasian approach in economics, evidenced by his reviews of Lange’s 1945 monograph (Friedman, 1946) and of the 1954 edition of the Elements of Pure Economics (Friedman, 1955), is well-known (De Vroey, 2009). Our paper will try to show that a similar opposition to the Walrasian approach is present in the works of Robert Solow. Solow is an eminent member of the group of economists who defended the banner of the neoclassical synthesis. Among the most prominent figures of this group, many considered that Walrasian general equilibrium was the potential foundation of the Keynesian theory. For Patinkin or Modigliani, the long term was the domain of the Walrasian theory and the short term was the domain of the Keynesian theory. But since the Keynesian theory was a general equilibrium theory it was a simplified and somewhat modified form of the Walrasian framework. This attitude towards Walras does not square with the attitude of Keynes himself who wrote to Hicks in 1934 that: “I shall hope to convince you some day that Walras’ theory and all the others along those lines are little better than nonsense!” A similar hostility can be found in the writing of some of Keynes’ closest disciples like Harrod’s review of The Elements of Pure Economics which attempted to show that “Marshall has far greater scope and depth than Walras.” (1956, p. 315-6) We will show that this hostility did not disappear completely in the thought of American neo-Keynesians. Our paper will track the anti-Walrasian attitudes of Solow in his methodological statements but also in the analytical content of some of his most emblematic papers. We will also use some archival material. We will pay particular attention to Solow’s correspondence with Frank Hahn in which he discussed the “axiomatic approach” writing that “If by serious theory you mean axiomatic theory, as you sometimes say, then we know it can hardly ever tell us anything truly interesting.” (April 1982) We will compare the approach of Solow, the approach of a typical Walrasian-Keynesian like Patinkin and the approach of Friedman.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)