ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: The distinction between normative and descriptive theory in behavioural economics: review of the discussion and philosophical evaluation.
Author: Malecka Magdalena
In behavioural economics, as well as in the philosophical analysis of behavioural economics and theories of decision making, the distinction between the normative and the descriptive (sometimes also called – positive, or empirical) theory is widely accepted (see: Heukelom 2015, Angner 2012, Hands 2009, Thaler 2000, Kahneman 2003, Baron 1994). The common view is that the neoclassical economics consists of normative theories or models, whereas the behavioural economics is descriptive and aims at explanation of how agents in economic settings ‘really behave’. The normative status of neoclassical models is often linked to their affinities with the so-called rational choice theory. It is claimed that these models do not provide ‘realistic’ account of economic behaviour, but characterize behaviour ‘as if it were rational’, or that they describe how rational agents should behave. The consequences of the distinction between the normative and descriptive theory have not gone undisputed. For instance, Todd and Gigerenzer (2012) have questioned the normative status of rational choice theory and thus neoclassical economics by arguing that theories in behavioural economics can also model rational behaviour (ecologically rational behaviour, as they call it). Furthermore, Gigerenzer claims that the ‘as if’ assumptions are used not only in normative, neoclassical economics, but also in the behavioural models. However, the debate in question leads to conceptual confusion concerning the relations between the normative status of a theory, its link to the notion of rationality, as well as to ‘as-if methodology’. There is also a lack of reflection on the justification for the very distinction, on the criterion that underlies it, as well as on the theoretical problems stemming from accepting it. The aim of the paper is to review the current state of debate on the issue, to list and to explicate the variety of senses in which the distinction normative/descriptive is used and to discuss and address the conceptual difficulties to which it leads.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)