ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Conjectural History in the Wealth of Nations? The Causal Role of Population in the Four Stages Theory of Adam Smith and the Scottish Historians
Author: Lange Jérôme
The group of eighteenth century Scottish scholars variously referred to as the “Scottish Historians” or the “Scottish Historical School” – among whom, most prominently, Adam Smith – were making use of a theory of progress, in which the determining factor of the social, economic, and political constitution of societies was taken to be their “mode of subsistence”. The development of societies was characterised as a succession of these modes of subsistence accompanied by ever more complex social organisation (Meek 1976). Hollander (1997) disputed the importance of the historical stage theory for Smith’s Wealth of Nations, the latter being, according to him, based on an analytical model not in contradiction with but distinct and independent from the stadial theory. It can be shown, on the contrary, that crucial elements of the Wealth of Nations, such as division of labour and capital accumulation, are directly linked to the stage theory and can best be understood by studying the latter. Although references to it are ubiquitous throughout the Wealth of Nations, however, the four stages theory is never laid out fully in this work. Especially, what is omitted is the crucial causal variable in the passage from one stage to the next. Smith explained what he saw as the causal mechanism at work in his Glasgow lectures on Jurisprudence. But the account of this is truncated in the first set of lecture notes to have surfaced, discovered and published by Cannan at the end of the nineteenth century. It appears clearly only in the more complete second set of lecture notes discovered in the mid-twentieth century and published in 1978 as part of the now standard Glasgow edition of Smith’s work. It appears clearly therein that in Smith’s account, the mode of subsistence is largely determined by the size of population. It is population growth which drives nations and societies through successive modes of subsistence, increasingly complex in terms of division of labour and technology. This explanation, commonly used in the accounts of the Scottish Historians, bears a striking resemblance to the one given by Ester Boserup in the twentieth century (1965 and 1981) in her study of the relationship between population growth and technological progress. In turn, this throws important light on the wider role of population growth in the Wealth of Nations, notably with respect to the definition of the market, the division of labour, and the accumulation of capital.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)