ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The development of transport demand modeling between economics and planning
Author: Dupont-Kieffer Ariane


Transportation is a complex concept for two reasons: first of all, transport demand is a derived demand so the initial step of any kind of analytical modeling is to understand the related activities generating transport needs. The derived nature of transportation explains that econometricians had to rephrase the utility function required for the modeling, and the work of McFadden in 1974 is the key element of this history of transport modeling and transport planning. The second result is that being at the core of economic and social activities at the local, national and international level, the building of transport infrastructures and of transport system is a strategic point of the political agenda for political and economic reasons, as we can see over the History with the building up of the roman empire road system and waterways, the building of roads, waterways and bridges under Henri the IV in France, the railways industry for the second industrial revolution etc. Being so strategic, transport research activities are by nature at the intersection of a knowledge approach and of a policy approach. This intertwining is obvious in terms of engineering (building of roads, bridges drove to develop special skills and this training was managed and structured by the creation of civil engineering schools). Engineers, as Jules Dupuit, turned in economics to deal with costs and fees issues in the 19th. Economics turned to Transportation lately with Pigou in 1920 with the investigation of the congestion prices and externalities issues. But the golden age of transport economics starts with transport modeling developed since the 1950’s to face major road construction needs. The structure of these macro-models (and also of the micro-models for traffic simulations), the econometrics and the data developed by the transport economists and engineers have to be understood by the fact that most of the time these models are the basis for implementing transport policy. The ultimate goal that drives transport modeling is obvious when the funding of the research comes directly from political authorities but is still at stake when it is not the case. We will show that researchers have internalized the explicit and latent concerns of politicians, private stakeholders and civil society. We will show and detail that the road demand models are intrinsically built to answer planning and policy needs and purposes. We will analyse that their content and their structure have mainly reflected the expectations of the politicians and of the administration in charge of the transport system, especially in terms of planning infrastructures building but also to plan the operation and the maintenance of the different mode systems (road, railways, transit, air and maritime). If the main concern in the sixties was the building of transport infrastructures, these transportation models had slightly to evolve in the seventies in order to answer and include the views and worries of the civil society about their transportation system and its externalities, and at the first rank safety issues and road risk. So over the period between 1965 to 1985, we will show how the transport models and the related econometrics and the related data collection have evolved in order to adopt a more comprehensive approach of the transportation system. Along this systematic approach, the models have firstly turned to the analysis of transport needs (infrastructure, affectation of traffic, intermodal coherence and even logistic models for freight deliveries) to the analysis of mobility needs and the articulation of transportation with the planned activities of the individual (e.g. activity based modeling). The second output of the evolution of society and of politicians’ expectations regarding transportation modeling is that the later has now to understand and measure the impacts of the transportation system on health (going further that road safety), on the environment (local air pollution, water pollution, greenhouse gas emission) and on land use. More recently, transport modelers are asked to think the transportation system as an equitable and livable mobility system, in short how the transportation system can contribute to an inclusive society. As transportation economics is seen by academics (and politicians) as an applied branch of economics, the paper will investigate the meaning and the different dimensions of “being applied”: how the intertwined relation between research and direct implementation and planning has framed the required and developed theory over the years (and in a different way among the countries), the data collection and the status of researchers working at the boundaries between empirical research and expertise.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.