ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Adam Smith, International Trade and the Division of Labour: How and Why Smith’s Trade Theory is Misunderstood
Author: Schumacher Reinhard


In recent decades, Adam Smith’s theory of foreign trade has experienced a renaissance due to its dynamic character, which allegedly foreshadowed the New Trade Theory. This revival has resulted in the fact that there are now three basic interpretations of Smith’s trade theory: first, the neoclassical theory of absolute advantage; second, an interpretation based on increasing returns; third, an interpretation of uneven development. These interpretations differ widely in several respects, especially the gains from international trade and how trade patterns evolve. However, they all agree that Smith’s theory of foreign trade predicts an international division of labour, in which each country specialises in the production of certain goods. In this article, I will present an interpretation that differs from all three interpretations mentioned. I will show that there is no such territorial division of labour on a worldwide scale in Smith's Wealth of Nations. Smith argues that nations will produce similar goods and that most foreign trade will take place in sophisticated manufactures between highly developed countries. An extension of the market leads to an increase in what is called mechanical division of labour. Together with increased competition, this makes foreign trade beneficial. However, Smith does not assume a territorial division of labour whereby each country specialises in the production of a few commodities. In Smith’s theory, countries are rather jack-of-all-trades than specialists. I will show that the attribution of an international division of labour to Smith rests on a misinterpretation of Smith’s writings, most importantly that his Wealth of Nations are read through the eye of modern modes of thoughts. I will show that the emergence of the three existing interpretations of Adam Smith’s trade theory can be explained by the development of international trade theory. The emergence of new theories also led to a reinterpretation of Smith’s theory, interpreting Smith as the respective forerunner of these theories. Thereby, different modes of thoughts are imposed on Smith. However, as I show, Smith’s theory can only be understood when not seen through any modern theoretical spectacles.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.