ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: In the search for a labour theory of value: Smith against Stewart and Ricardo on the two states of society
Author: Ruellou Thomas
Neo-ricardian economics surely inherit from the early controversies surrounding the so-called “labour theory of value”. In this respect, prices are equal to labour-values under specific conditions (namely a zero-profit rate or identical techniques across sectors). A labour theory of value is often seen in Adam Smith's “early and rude” state without surplus (1776: I.vi.1-4). Yet, such a pre-ricardian attempt is deemed limited as, departing from this “early and rude” state, Smith would have replaced this labour theory of value by the “component parts of price” in the “advanced” state where surplus and capital accumulation are met (Kurz & Salvadori 1995: 6-7). I claim Smith wasn't dealing with production in the analytical sense of an input-ouput circular flow, and therefore lacked a proper theory of production. Hence, he didn't frame a labour theory of value in the first state. The dividing line he drawn between the two states wasn't grounded on the validity of, or changes in, the rule governing relative prices. On the contrary, Smith's biographer and first teacher of political economy in Great Britain Dugald Stewart provides a first step towards a ricardian approach in his courses on the theory of value (1808–1809). My argument is that the source of the received reading of Smith's sixth chapter (1776: I.vi), dealing with the extent of exchangeable value, should paradoxically be sought for in the fifth (1776: I.v) dealing with “labour commanded”. Taking quantities of labour mentioned in the early and rude state of (1776: I.vi) as the rule regulating relative prices actually amounts to directly transpose them from those mentioned in (1776: I.v) (Ricardo 1817; Douglas 1928; Bladen 1975; O'Donnell 1990; Khalil 1991; Henry 2000; Naldi 2003; 2013; Peach 2009; 2010). Yet, in the latter chapter, labour was only used by Smith as a measuring item of value. To counter this received view, I show that Smith's moral philosophy accounts for quantities of labour in a roundabout way, from a spectator's viewpoint: labour isn't an input but is only commanded on the market. Second, a technique of production not being depicted, his texts can hardly be read with a classical system of prices in mind. By sharing specific assumptions supporting a labour theory of value with Ricardo, Stewart can fit in a neo-ricardian framework. Stewart and Ricardo did define conditions for which prices reflect labour-values. However, Stewart only focused on the distribution of surplus and thus maintained that prices differ from labour-values because of profit, contrary to Ricardo whose framework is more general.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)