ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Reshaping Standard Microeconomics For Political Action: Kenneth J. Arrow and Thomas C. Schelling’s RAND Corporation projects on Racial Issues
Author: Chassonnery Zaigouche Cleo, Larrouy Lauren
The present paper focuses on Arrow’s and Schelling’s contribution to the study of racial inequalities in the late 1960s and early 1970s. The statistical theory of discrimination (Arrow 1972) and the model of segregation (Schelling 1970) were both published in the context of a RAND publication (Pascal 1972). Since its creation in 1945, two main features characterize the RAND Corporation. From a theoretical point of view, research programs are based i) on a « systemic analysis » and ii) on interdisciplinarity (Sent, 2007). We will underline how (i) certain methods employed within RAND Corp. during the Cold War like its “interdisciplinary approach” or its “system analysis” are applied in Arrow and Schelling’s work on racial inequalities, and (ii) how certain tools which became the core of neoclassical economics are at the same time pervasive and challenged in Arrow and Schelling’s respective work. In that sense, our analysis is slightly different than Amadae’s one (2003) who sees in Arrow and Schelling’s work the illustration of the domination of rational choice theory in neoclassical economics. In our opinion, the two contributions have in common to be embedded in a neoclassical framework and illustrate a movement to amend this general framework for policy purpose. They both highlight some methodological and analytical breaks from standard microeconomics on two specific aspects: emergent phenomena, and the unintentional characters of economic equilibrium. We argue that both Arrow and Schelling’s conception of economics and economic models stands for “open-systems” and no longer for “self-contained worlds” like in standard microeconomics and game theory (Lawson, 1997, 2003 ; Hodgson, 2000 ; and Morgan, 2002). The “open-system” methodology can be considered as grounds for heterodox economics (e.g. see Hodgson, 1988; Dunn, 2001). By coupling, economics and sociology methodology, for instance, both Arrow and Schelling assume that economics cannot be considered as a closed system. Besides, the dynamic and emergent systems they both formalize and the – mainly sociological and psychological – determinants of individuals’ behavior they incorporate in their formalization threaten the closed-system methodology of standard microeconomics. We will therefore assess whether this eventually endangers the internal validity of their respective theory and models The paper aims also at highlighting that the way both Arrow and Schelling conceive the role of economics as a science for action, has impacted their conception of economic theories and models. This relationship between economics and political action implies the need to enrich standard microeconomics and even to reshape its fundamental behavioral hypothesis. We will therefore assess the epistemological status of Arrow and Schelling works, i.e. how they shape a new trend of scientific knowledge, by their specific methodologies, and how their works stress the usual dichotomy between economics as a normative or a positive science. Methods have consequences on political actions and Policy recommendations. The tiny threshold between prediction and explanation in Arrow and Schelling’s works imply a reflection on their epistemological status, especially because their respective amendments to standard theory are driven by the necessity of policy recommendations. The paper is structured by the comparison of the two authors on their methodological choices, especially in the way their modelization answer their criticism of Becker’s methods (section 1); on their epistemology, regarding the type of systems entailed in their model — i.e., open or closed (section 2) and on their conception of science and expertise (section 3).
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)