ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: On the Nature of Sraffa’s Contribution to Classical Economics
Author: Sinha Ajit


In this paper I will highlight the entanglement of two theoretical problems in classical economics: (i) the question of the scale by which the value of a commodity can be measured and (ii) what causes a commodity to acquire value to begin with. In Adam Smith the problem of value was posed in the context of change in the value of a commodity over a period of time. So the question was: what scale to use to measure the change? It was the search for the proper scale that led Adam Smith to the question of the ultimate cause of value. Adam Smith argued that the ultimate cause of value lies in the primordial productive activity when man works against nature directly. There are two aspects to this primary exchange between man and nature: (i) it is a laboring activity where man sacrifices his ease and comfort and (ii) it results in appropriation of income. Adam Smith argued that in the primordial state the two aspects of the exchange are united in the same individual, which results in a simple rule of exchange for commodities; but once appropriation gets disconnected from the laboring activity, no such simple rule of exchange holds any longer. He emphasized the relation of appropriation of income with value and developed a theory of value which is mainly a problem of accounting of income given its rule of distribution from outside. Ricardo, in opposition to Adam Smith, emphasized the relation of laboring activity with value. He argued that even though, in general, it cannot be established that the laboring activity per say determines the value of a commodity at a point of time, one could argue that changes in value of a commodity can be directly related to changes in laboring activity, which is the ultimate cause of value. It was in this context that Ricardo had to face the problem of the scale or the ‘invariable measure’ of value—a problem that he could not resolve. Marx went a step further than Ricardo and argued that one can establish a direct relation between the exchange-values of commodities at a point of time with the laboring activity. But his solution of the transformation of values to prices of production also did not succeed. Sraffa reconstructs the classical paradigm by first removing the problematic of ultimate cause from the theory of value and then formulating the problem of value in terms of accounting of a given net output and its distribution in terms of wages and the rate of profits. In this context Sraffa showed that income distribution can be taken as given from outside independently of exchange ratios of commodities and that it can be shown that exchange ratios of commodities are completely determined once income distribution is specified. In this context Sraffa needed a scale of measure that would not be affected by changes in distribution, which he discovered in the Standard commodity.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.