ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Rousseau and Smith on envy in commercial societies
Author: PIGNOL Claire, Walraevens Benoît


Paper with Benoît Walraevens Envy takes in Rousseau’s thought a very prominent place. It is a malevolent passion, caused by the comparison with other’s happiness, pleasure or wealth, leading to both misfortune and dishonesty of the one who experiences it. According to Rousseau, this passion, whose origin lies in any form of socialization, is made worse with the development of exchanges and the (concomitant?) increase of wealth and inequality. His condemnation of the development of market relations is mainly due to the development of envy in such “commercial societies”, as Smith labelled them. As we will show, Smith shares a similar conception of envy: it is defined as a malevolent passion that relies on (has to do with or founded on) comparison and as a source of misfortune. But envy doesn’t play such an important role in Smith’s vision of the process of socialization and of market society. How can we explain that Smith and Rousseau reached opposite conclusions on the predominance of envy in commercial societies from rather similar conceptions of that passion? That’s the problem our paper deals with. To analyze it, we focus on the comparison process at stake in envy. In particular, we analyze the two passions that, according to Rousseau or Smith, appear in a similar process of comparison, but also through an identification with others, and lead to behaviors that are at the opposite of envious behavior: pity in Rousseau’s thought; sympathy in Smith’s. These passions, though, play a very different role in their respective systems of morality: whereas, for Rousseau, envy prevents human beings from being sensitive to pity, Smith claims that sympathy precludes the development of envy. The existence of envy in market society thus appears as an exception in Smith’s thought, whereas it is the rule in Rousseau’s.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.