ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The Doctrine of Comparative Costs and the Theory of Values: A Critical Overview of the Competing Approaches in the 1930s
Author: Tabuchi Taichi


This paper gives a historical analysis of how the concept of comparative advantage has developed from Ricardo to modern economics in the light of value theory, focusing especially on the controversy in the 1930s. In the 1930s, there were three competing approaches to the theory of comparative advantage: Jacob Viner’s real-costs approach; Gottfried Haberler’s opportunity-costs approach; and Bertil Ohlin’s factor endowment approach. It is reputedly said that soon the last two of them overwhelmed the first, and, by the hands of Paul Samuelson, emerged the Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson model as the new mainstream theory of international trade after World War II. However, after taking a closer look at the process, we will find some problems and puzzles in it: 1) Viner and Haberler rivaled each other but had a common misconception that Ricardo’s theory of comparative costs was based on the labour theory of value. They insisted on doing away with the labour theory of value from the doctrine of comparative costs, and replacing it with their own value theories, i.e. the real cost theory of value in Viner and the opportunity cost theory of value in Haberler. 2) Viner did not succeed in finding a common unit to measure the subjective costs of labour and capital (i.e. the irksomeness of labour and the abstinence or ‘waiting’). On the other hand, Haberler’s approach was successful in building a theory of international values with multiple factors, introducing the substitution-curve based on Austrian value theory, nowadays known as transformation curve or production possibility frontier, which, as Viner criticized in an appropriate manner, had the fatal flaws: it assumed fixed factor supplies and factor indifference as to alternative uses. 3) On the contrary to popular perception, Ohlin showed disdain for the concept of ‘comparative advantage’, and gave weight on money costs against real costs. 4) It is curious that Samuelson, who later synthesized the three approaches into the HOS model, insisted that the real costs and opportunity costs approaches could go together in 1938, but he criticized the product of compromise of both sides as ‘a rather awkward mumbo-jumbo’ in 1948. As a result of the synthesis of the three approaches, the framework of pure exchange economy has been formulated and established under 2-country 2-commodity 2-factor model. The paper will try to provide a critical perspective of these problems and puzzles.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.