ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: The norm of equality in Amartya Sen’s conception of social justice: from “Equality of what?” to “Why equality?”
Author: POIRAUD Cyrielle


The issue of equality has been established as a fundamental one in the field of social justice, in which it is widely discussed. The debate mainly concerns which type of equality should be adopted: equality of resources, of chances, of capabilities, etc., are some of the possible answers to the question “Equality of what?”, raised by Amartya Sen, firstly in his eponymous Tanner Lecture (1979) – published one year after – and later developed in his book Inequality Reexamined (1992). However, both writings do not focus exactly on the same issues and this difference is characteristic of the evolution of Sen’s thought, notably concerning his defense of “basic capabilities” as the right “space” of equality. Now, this notion of “space” is central for our research. It denotes a specific tendency for contemporary social justice theories, as Sen suggests: they all take equality into consideration, but as seeking for one particular space in which it should be realized, allowing at the same time inequalities to raise legitimately in some other spaces. In parallel, Sen asks another question: “Why equality?”, involving a more general perspective, seeking to establish the reasons for the necessity of equality as a norm for social justice theories. The paper aims at showing the importance of this “why equality” regarding Sen’s own idea of justice, although he seems to evacuate the issue (1992, p. 17; 2009, p.295). Evidence of his concern for some kind of fundamental and general idea of equality – not only in terms of space – can be found notably in The Idea of Justice (2009). Now, the treatment of “why equality?” is to be related to his conception of impartiality, deeply involved in the foundations of the “egalitarian formula” (2009, p. 293), as an imperative for any theory of justice: without the impartiality requirement being met, a normative theory cannot be viable (2009, p. 353). Moreover the analysis of the distinction between “equality of what” and “why equality” integrates some aspects of the discussion concerning the transcendental and the comparative approaches, and the study of equality as based on impartiality helps in arguing for the presence of some transcendental dimension in Sen’s idea of justice. The paper thus aims at shedding light on this dual conception of equality, which tends to reveal two different forms of it: a particular one, related to the concept of “space” (sometimes called “focal variable”), and a general, even formal one, related to the ideas of equal treatment, equal consideration, moral equality, etc., usually based on a Kantian perspective. And as impartiality is deeply connected to this general form of equality in Sen’s thought, regarding his treatment of “open impartiality” and human rights, it shows the relevance of the transcendental approach for his own conception, although he explicitly rejects it and connects impartiality to the comparative approach.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.