ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: An appraisal of the subjective value concept of Graslin, Turgot, and Condillac: 1767-1776
Author: Yamamoto Eiko
Anne Robert Jacques Turgot (1727-81) and ÉtienneBonnot de Condillac (1714-80) discussed subjective value with the concepts of need, utility, and scarcity in ValeursetMonnaies (1769) and in Le Commerce et le Gouvernement (1776).It is fair tosay that each had distinct views of subjective value.As Carl Menger (1840-1921) frequently referred to theirremarksabout subjective valuein his Grundsätze der Volkswirtschaftslehre(1871) and acknowledged their contribution, Valeurs et Monnaies by Turgot and Le Commerce et le Gouvernement by Condillac are often classified into pioneer works of subjective value theory and of marginal utility concept. However, Turgot and Condillac owed their views of subjective valueto EssaiAnalytique (1767) by Jean-Joseph-Louis Graslin (1727-90)who, prior to them, showed a consistent subjective value theory by the concepts of utility, need, and scarcity,and strongly accused of theoretical peculiarity of Physiocracy.It can be seen from a chronological point of view: Turgot wrote ValeursetMonnais shortly after that he awarded and criticized Graslin’sEssaiAnalytique, and adaptedGraslin’s theoretical essences of subjective value to his own Valeurs et Monnaies.It turns out by the fact that Turgot’s theoretical structure ofvaleurestimtive and l’ordred’utilité are similar to Graslin’svaleurdirecte and l’ordre des richesses. Besides, Turgot’s ValeursetMonnaies had no direct influence upon Condillac’sLe Commerce et le Gouvernement at all because Valeurs et Monnais, an unfinished draft, had been kept in Turgot’s documents while they were alive. Although Condillac had had no information about Turgot’s Valeurs et Monnaies,hewould have certainly recognizedGraslin’sEssaiAnalytique since Condillac’s opinions on the subjective value in Le Commerce et le Gouvernementare close to or opposite to Graslin’s. Actually, regardless of the emphasis on need,utility,and scarcity,the value theories of Turgot andCondillacresulted in labor value rather than the combinationbetweensubjective value and labor value.Because their determinant factors of value were human resources and labor. Moreover, their views included the physiocratic concept, which led them to be as mediators between Physiocracy and Classical school; while generally uncelebrated Graslin, who entirely rejected Physiocracy and maintained a consistent subjective value theory, was one of the remarkable pioneers of Neo-classicalschool. This presentation clarifies the similarities, the differences, and the relationship among these three authors’subjective value arguments focusing on Turgot’s term “faculté” and Condillac’s term “industrie,”and then reaffirms their commitments to the development process relate to the subjective value theory in the late eighteenth century.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)