ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: On the Difficult Transition from the Mediterranean to European Economic Thought: Ferdinando Galiani’s Dialogues sur le commerce des bleds
Author: AĞIR Seven , AKDERE CINLA, Ozveren Eyup


On the Difficult Transition from the Mediterranean to European Economic Thought: Ferdinando Galiani’s Dialogues sur le commerce des bleds Among the numerous contributions of Joseph Schumpeter in his History of Economic Analysis, of particular interest to us are (1) his attempt to bring Adam Smith, posthumously inaugurated founding father of modern economic theory, down to earth, and (2) his favorable coverage of Italian—and Spanish—economists. Precisely because Schumpeter knew well the Italian economists, he could reevaluate Smith’s contribution in a new light vis-à-vis his contemporaries thereby replacing his exaggerated originality with his synthetic ability. Throughout his text, Schumpeter also alluded to the phenomena of "lost knowledge" in economic thought to which he attributed great importance. This paper takes off from where Schumpeter leaves us by focusing on the Neapolitan economist Ferdinando Galiani’s Dialogues sur le Commerce des Blés which was an intervention to the French debate over grain policy. We argue that it was less than fully understood and appreciated in its time because its roots—as far as content as well as style were concerned—lay elsewhere, in the early modern Mediterranean world. We take up a discussion of Mediterranean economic thought and grain provisioning policy by recourse to Habsburg and Bourbon Spain, and North African and Ottoman sources in order to re-embed this text into its Mediterranean context. We then demonstrate how renewed interest in Galiani’s book emerged only after the belated development of European economic thought of a historical and institutional kind. This is to do with the fact that the late 18th-early 19th century European economic thought favored a shift towards abstract and internally consistent theory whereas both what preceded it at home as well as in the Mediterranean world were far more historically and institutionally sensitive and policy oriented. The full value of Galiani’s Dialogues sur le commerce des bleds was hence lost to a European audience. This was also because the transition from Mediterranean to European economic thought which Galiani attempted to make was cut short by a simultaneous shift from early modernity to modernity. We argue that Galiani made a move from the Mediterranean world to Europe at a time when this latter shifted from early modern to modern economic thought. He was the last of the early modern Mediterranean economists to find himself some room in European economic thought which was however subject also to a major transformation from within. Galiani’s personal move from Naples to Paris and then back to Naples—much against his wishes—has a symbolic bearing in this respect.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.