ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Is there a “new” “mainstream” behavioral economics?
Author: Truc Alexandre
Many recent discussions in philosophy of economics are concerned with the definition of behavioral economics (BE). By using a set of characteristics and examining different research programs, most authors try to define BE in comparison to “mainstream economics” or “orthodox economics” given the identified set of characteristics they use. One dominant idea that emerges from this literature is that behavioral economics could be regarded as an orthodox research program in some aspects, especially when compared to what is sometimes identified as an “old behavioral economics”. The aim of this paper is to critically map the main arguments and methods used in this literature, in order to offer new ways to frame BE as a sub-discipline of economics. In this respect, we will focus on two arguments. We will develop the idea that behavioral economists sometimes position themselves within “mainstream economics” not because they believe that it is the only possible identification but in order to persuade economists of the value of psychology in understanding individual behavioral, and not to rebuild an “orthodox” program as it is sometimes argued. The epistemological position they state is more often than not the results of strategic thinking. Most notably, concerning the use of mathematics, we will defend the idea that for behavioral economists, the use of mathematical models is part of this scientific strategy to persuade economists rather than a real methodological commitment. We will also argue that most of the literature examines “mainstream economics” and BE using too restrictive concepts, such as the orthodox/heterodox opposition. We want to develop an approach that will allow us to foster another conception of behavioral economics. Rather than trying to compare BE to “mainstream economics”, we will focus our understanding of BE as part of a pluralistic mainstream. We will characterize behavioral economics by its diversity of approach, rather than to try to identify a set of defining epistemological characteristics. The ultimate goal of the paper is to set up a framework allowing us to develop the sociological aspects of the link between “mainstream economics” and BE in addition to its epistemological aspects.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)