ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Harrington on Equality, Agrarian Law, and Political Justice
Author: Jaffro Laurent, Selzner Cyril
In James Harrington’s Commonwealth of Oceana (1656), ’equal’ and ‘unequal’ qualify what he calls the ‘balance of power’ (power being understood as an external and material good, distinct from political authority), which depends on the way lands are distributed, that is, on the agrarian law. As he puts it in his System of Politics: ‘Distribution of shares in land as to the three grand interests, the king, the nobility and the people, must be equal or unequal.’ There cannot be any predominant interest , and thus any government, without some inequality in that distribution. Any agrarian law involves some degree of inequality. In a different but related sense, equality characterises a situation in which the balance of power is not endangered by a contrary agrarian law. For instance, in the case of democracy, if the (unequal in the first sense) distribution of lands is not the one that democracy requires, the power of the people may be overcome by the power of the few or of one (the monarch), and thus the commonwealth cannot be equal (in the second sense). Harrrington also draws on a concept of equality when he deals with the ‘balance of authority’ and defends bicameralism, i.e. the division between the senate and the popular assembly. Without a proper constitutional balance, decisions would not be ‘equal’ and there would be no public or general interest. If the role of the senate goes beyond preparing the options between which the popular assembly has to choose, then the commonwealth cannot be ‘equal’. This constitutional equality roughly corresponds to what we call political justice, the contrary of which consists in various forms of tyranny. One of Harrington’s major claims is that constitutional equality or equality ‘in the superstructure’ (his expression) closely depends on the balance of power and thus on agrarian law. The aim of the paper is to explain and that dependence and also to assess the procedural (vs. natural) dimension of Harrington’s republican understanding of justice.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)