ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Gluts result from Inequality: the Italian Judgement on England’s Crises in the Early Nineteenth Century
Author: Poettinger Monika
A preliminary survey of Italian literature of the nineteenth century discloses only a vague awareness of the momentous change from a traditional society largely based on agriculture to a society centered in cities and divided in new classes. The perception of modernity was confined to a general reappraisal of agricultural life, in positive or negative; to the discontent for the growing bureaucratization of life, in the last part of the century particularly in relation with the setting up of the national state; and to the depiction of changes in the structure of society, although limited to the few urban spaces influenced by a slow process of industrialization. In Italy, the life of the common man was still much more influenced by famine than economic turmoil. Famine was the recurrent form of crisis for the whole century and as such widely discussed and represented in literature as in journals. Overproduction crises, instead, almost unknown as a contemporary reality, came to coincide in the imagination of Italians with the idea of England itself, a nation rich and powerful as any, but plagued by a diffused misery, unfamiliar in such measure on the Continent. The alarmed reports on mass unemployment, bankruptcies and stock market crashes were so interpreted as a proof that an economic development based on agriculture and productions related to silk, cotton, wine and oil, would prove much more stable, not only in economic terms but also socially, than English industrialization. Only in the second half of the century, could the universal expositions of London and Paris shake such certainties. A particular trait of the Italian debates on industrialism was the widespread belief that English crises were caused mainly by its century long unequal distribution of income. For the most part, Italian economists and intellectuals refuted the theses of Sismondi and Say, while adopting a free-trade stance combined with a measure of state control over industrialization processes. Civilization, in particular, came so to mean an economic modernization resulting from ta slow spread of manufactories in the countryside, maintaining the old social order and an equal distribution of income. The paper will analyze this response of Italian economists and intellectuals to England’s crises in the most diffused journals of the first half of the nineteenth century, from Il Conciliatore to the Antologia, from the Annali to the the Biblioteca Italiana. A brief review of popular and illustrated magazines will underline how this stance would persist as an ideological prejudice on the inequality of the English society long into the second half of the nineteenth century.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)