ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Adam Smith: The Servant of Two Masters?
Author: WITZTUM Amos
Adam Smith has now been claimed by both neo-classical economics and experimentally based behavioural economics. In the one case he is the forefather of the self-interested behaviour which unintentionally translates into social benefits through the working of the invisible hand. In the other, he is the forefather of the socially minded individuals who (perhaps intentionally) rescue the competitive paradigm from the predicament of prisoners’ dilemmas. Can he really serve both masters? Inadvertently, this debate has re-ignited the famous Das Adam Smith Problem. The question at the heart of the battle between behavioural economics and the paradigmatic core of neo-classical economics is exactly the same question which was raised by the original Das Adam Smith Problem: are people self-interested or are they socially minded individuals who always employ ‘sympathy’ when dealing with others? The received answer to this question is that self-interest is the prudent manner of caring for one’s self which does not preclude being conscious and even caring about the other. In saying so, scholars have not suggested a change to the notion of self-interest as it is manifested in the WN but simply argued that self-interest is only one aspect of Smith’s complex conception of the human character. The most extreme expression of this is Friedman’s claim that self-interest describes how people interact in their economic life and sympathy shows how they interact outside the economic sphere. I have argued elsewhere that such a position is logically incoherent. The question that arises from Das Adam Smith problem is not whether individuals have an ‘other regarding’ capacity but rather, would the ‘other regarding’ aspect of the human character affect the way in which people pursue their ‘own regard’. Given that people’s interest in the others may vary—even though we all have the capacity to feel sympathy with them—would the way in which they pursue their own affairs vary too? The received view about the solution of Das Adam Smith problem is very much in line with the neo-classical paradigm. Behavioural economics, on the other hand, has offered a change in the behaviour of the socially minded individual. According to this position, by replacing the traditional self-interested agent who kept falling into the trap of prisoner’s dilemmas with a new form of behaviour which is socially minded, we can see that Smith’s idea of the WN works. In other words, the agent behind the WN is not the self-interested rational utility maximiser but rather the socially minded rational utility maximiser. So while the behavioural approach is more sensible than the received view of Smith’ scholarship, it suffers one major problem: they are all rational utility maximiser! The problem with this approach is that it does not really distinguish between the two types of agents. As they are all rational utility maximisers, they are all, in a sense, self-interested even if they appear to have social considerations. This is not what we find in Smith’s TMS. Moreover, it is not clear that people who are socially minded would engage in competitive exchanges the likes of which are captured by the notion of Nash Equilibrium. People with ethical principles would not obviously engage in ‘best response’ kind of interaction. Instead, they may be engaged in co-operative behaviour which, it must be made clear, is not the same as collusion and which may require different solution concepts than mere equilibrium. In the case of Adam Smith there are three elements to this problem: (a) the unity of human nature allows for a selfish type of socially minded individuals who would not behave very differently to the expectations of the rational utility maximiser; (b) there is an implicit evolutionary game with two very clear Evolutionary Stable Equilibria ; (c) the outcome of the evolutionary game dictates whether competitive behaviour and consequently, problems of the prisoner’s dilemma type, arise. The key parameter which influences the outcome in (b) (and subsequently (c)) is the Smithian concept of social distance.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)