ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: One fiction meets another: Adam Smith's early state of society and the stage of hunters
Author: Okan Ecem


Right from the beginning of the Wealth of Nations (1776), in the Introduction and Plan of the Work a profound distinction appears between an early state of society and an advanced state. These two states of society represent two different degrees of economic development which are characterized primarily by the existence or the non-existence of capital accumulation. On the other hand, according to Smith’s theory of four stages, every society goes through four different types of subsistence: hunting, pasturing, agriculture and commerce. This historical progress culminates in the European commercial societies with more and more powerful governments and justice administration. This paper attempts to reveal that there is a distinction between these two narratives: the early state of society and the very first stage of the “theory of four stages”, namely the stage of hunters are not synonyms. Indeed, these are two different fictions with two distinct purposes. The fiction of “the stage of hunters” is an attempt to fulfill the aim of Smith’s political theory. I seek to demonstrate that the very object of the theory of stages is to establish a starting point of a theory of jurisprudence which will later be called a theory of state. Smith opposes the social contract theory’s narrative on the origin of the state, and he elaborates his own with the help of the theory of four stages. By doing so, he intends to complete or even refine David Hume’s explanation on the origin of the justice and the state in his Treatise on Human Nature (1739-1740). On the other hand, the fiction of the “early state of society” is an attempt to fulfill the aim of Smith’s economic theory. The early state represents a theoretical model of a non-capitalist market economy. Smith seeks to establish his economic theory on the basis of this fiction. He tries to explain the economic development of nations by comparing the early state of economy which corresponds to a non-capitalist market economy, and the advanced state of economy that represents a capitalistic economy.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.