ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Sophistication or Multiplication: what happens to models of man when economists try to be more realistic
Author: AVTONOMOV Vladimir
Model of man in economic science is a highly simplified and abstract representation of human nature used by economists constructing their theories. Without such models a systematic theory pretending to make definite conclusions and forecasts is impossible. In the history of economics we may perceive the periods when the model of man becomes more abstract. The marginal revolution of 1870-1890-ies and the formalist revolution of 1950-ies may be cited as examples. During such periods the analytic (mathematical) instruments used by economists become more powerful . But at the same time he tension increases between abstract assumptions of economic theory and economic reality. Resulting progress in economic theory consists of two subperiods: a stepwise deepening of abstraction and a gradual approximation to reality. During the second subperiod the model of man should be corrected without impairing the technical level achieved. There are two ways of attaining this goal. The first one is to make the model of man more sophisticated, to loosen the simplifying assumptions. A typical example may be the bounded rationality model of Herbert Simon. The model becomes more sophisticated because the rationality assumption is weakened. But on this way the modelling technique becomes more complex, so the majority of economists tend to prefer the keep the more abstract old model of man. The second way presumes that we keep the old model of man but introduce an additional one that will take the burden of approximation to reality. This additional model should be used for a special groop of economic agents. An example of this approach is given by the theory of entrepreneurship. F.Knight and J.Schumpeter keep the rational maximizer describing the equilibrium system of perfect competition or Kreislauf. But for bringing the system out of equilibrium (by Schumpeter) or expaining the phenomenon of profit (by Knight) they introduce a special agent – the entrepreneur. This special agent is characterised by specific personal traits, allowing them to perform the entrepreneurial function. The same problem was solved by L.von Mises in a different way – he imbued every human agent with enrepreneurial traits – that is, he followed the first approach. Another example can be the theory of financial markets. The theory of efficient markets assumed that the participants of financial markets are highly rational experts, able to calculate an optimal choice in no time. But R.Shiller and others discovered a lot of anomalies signalling irrational behaviour in financial markets. They could be explained either by making the modelof man less rational (as in the theory of behavioural finance) or introducing an additional agent – a layman led by irrational impulses.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)