ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Laziness : from cabaret to Malibu
Author: Hawi Rima


The aim of this paper is to show how laziness has been used as an argument by economists to maintain workers in poverty but most of all to justify inequalities. Hard work and material success are the only path to salvation according to Calvin (1508-1564) and the Reformation: quality of fruits proves quality of trees. Consequently poverty is a fault and misery a sin of the lazy man. Progressively this idea has had social consequences in Protestant’s countries: the end of alms and the enthronement of the moral authority of the contractor – the one who gives works to men. But this idea has been also used in a way or another by economists in capitalist countries through centuries in order to encourage workers to work harder and longer accepting hard working conditions, bad wages, and illegitimating some redistributive policies. Mercantilists used the argument of laziness to justify low wages because according to them high wages and free time would increase laziness of the workers and ruin the economy. Consequently, as we will show in the first part, some authors from the 17th until the 19th century will recommend moral discipline in order to fight inequalities and teach workers how not to spend money in the cabaret and how to change their behavior. We will also show that different reactions will emerge in the 19th century refusing those hard work and living conditions: from workers themselves, from authors showing, in one hand, the more workers create wealth in the capitalist system the poorest they get (Sismondi, Marx…) and, in another, authors fighting for workers’ rights for laziness in a word of technical progress (Lafargue…). Even if the conditions of the working class have changed in the 20th century, the guilt speech addressed to the workers asking them more contributions and efforts has not disappeared. It is often analyzed in sociology but as we will show, in the second part, it has been present in economics debates in order to illegitimate redistributive policy. This is obvious in what has been known as the Malibu discussion (1993) related to Rawls’ principle of difference in his theory of social justice. Economists such as Musgrave (1974) argued that the maximization of the situation of the least advantaged in the society “is to the advantage of recluses, saints and (non–consulting) scholars who earn but little and hence will not have to contribute greatly to redistribution”.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.