ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Bifurcations, fragmentation and certification: three keys for understanding the development of economic theory
Author: Pensieroso Luca, VROEY Michel de


Our paper pursues the ambitious aim of shedding new light on a most general topic, the development of economics from the marginal revolution to the present. Its originality lies in its using original notions – bifurcation, fragmentation and certification – for this purpose. The bifurcation notion is draw from Leijonhufvud’s decision-tree vision of the development of economics. Constructing economic theory amounts to making decisions about basic methodological nodes. The choices they involve can be compared to forks or bifurcation on a road. Choosing one fork rather than another puts the theory on different tracks. The fragmentation notion refers to the fact that, from the marginalist revolution to the present time, economics has become more and more disparate. It has testified firstly to a split between different approaches, more or less rivals, the neoclassical one being the most prominent one, and secondly to a fragmentation inside these approaches into separate fields associated with specific objects of research and specific scientific communities. An implication of this evolution is that one should no longer speak about a single neoclassical theory but rather about the neoclassical approach as composed of separate theoretical streams. Progress and methodological changes take place at the level of these streams rather than at the neoclassical approach level. We introduce the certification notion in order to make sense of the present-day strong polarization between mainstream and non-mainstream economics. Certification has become a main fixtures of contemporary life. The issuance of numerous rankings – of journals, departments and even individual economists – testifies to its presence in economics. Certification in economics is methodologically grounded in the same way as granting the fair trade label is conditioned on the satisfaction of given standards. Standards for what is deemed a good theoretical practice can be identified using Leijonhufvud’s bifurcation notion. We will show that they arose endogenously and locally, i.e. in the different subfields of the profession. Belonging to the mainstream is a matter of abiding by these standards.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.