ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Steering the Invisible Hand: Normativity and Self-Implementing Technologies in Postwar General Equilibrium Theory
Author: Boldyrev Ivan


In their classic book, Ingrao and Israel (1990) developed the analysis of general equilibrium theory and claimed that in stability analysis, two schools could be distinguished: ‘objective-descriptive’ and ‘utopian-normative.’ While the first school was mainly preoccupied with the analysis of adjustment processes, mainly tâtonnement, another one was thinking of realizing equilibration and thus of enacting equilibrium through planning. In this talk, I demonstrate, first, that the key economists involved in the stability analysis – Kenneth Arrow and Leonid Hurwicz – were not only biographically linked to the ideas of socialism. Their work in the 1950s also demonstrates important conceptual affinities to the ‘utopian-normative’ tendency in the general equilibrium analysis. In particular, drawing on my previous work (Boldyrev and Ushakov 2015), I show how various adjustment techniques were reformulated as the internal modeling technologies demonstrating the ways to implement the ideal equilibrium state described by the model. While Hurwicz later re-functioned these early interests and switched to mechanism design, Arrow seemed to have abandoned them altogether. However, Arrow’s (1953) seminal contribution to the theory of general equilibrium under uncertainty demonstrates a very similar pattern that later became the foundation of modern theory of finance. Implementing there amounted to completing the market (Boldyrev 2016).

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.