ABSTRACT OF PAPER
Title: Beyond Enlightened Common Sense: How Economics Became a Science
Author: Ananyin Oleg
Economic knowledge gained scientific status in the Age of Reason. From the chronological point of view this claim is widely accepted (see Gronewegen, 1989, 2002), but the causal link between the two phenomena is often overlooked. Meanwhile the birth of economics as a science is much more than just an episode in the history of a particular discipline. It was the first attempt to expand the Enlightenment vision of science beyond natural sciences, to adapt the ideals of modern science to studies of the human world thus emancipating the social thought from the tenets of common sense and philosophy. How was this challenging task accomplished? Paradoxically, these questions attracted little attention among both historians of the economic thought and experts on the Enlightenment science. While historians of economic thought tend to take the emergence of economic science for granted as an evolutionary outcome of a long history of knowledge accumulation, the Enlightenment scholarship often identifies emerging political economy with the rise of ‘laissez faire’ ideology, i.e. see it rather in the context of political philosophy, and not of science. In both cases the gap caused by the transition from common sense reasoning to science drops out of sight. Analyses of ancient and scholastic legacies (Schumpeter-1954, Pribram-1983), of personal contributions (Letwin-1963, Aspromourgos-1996), or of some formative ideas, such as ‘surplus’ (Marx-1859), ‘production’ (Foucault-1966), ‘capital’ (Eagly-1974), ‘conservation principle (Mirowski-1989), etc., however insightful they are, do not fill in this gap. The paper aims at reconstructing the context and logic of the formation of scientific economics as an integral part of the Enlightenment science project. It is suggested that the birth of political economy was an outcome of heterogeneous trends unleashed by economic, political, and intellectual changes during the Enlightenment. Received views of economic and political order, conventional vision of history and science were contested to open way for new ideas, but also to create demand for objective and reliable knowledge. It is argued that political economy took its shape in a joint and contradictory process of transition from traditional to enlightened common sense and from common sense to science. Enlightenment philosophy and contemporary natural sciences served as an important source of inspiration for the leading economic writers from William Petty to Adam Smith in their efforts to establish the new science.
Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back
Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)