ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Isaak Rubin's research project: a reconstruction
Author: Melnik Denis


Denis Melnik National Research University ‘Higher School of Economics’ (Moscow,Russia) dmelnik@hse.ru The fate of Isaak Rubin’s theoretical legacy is quite paradoxical. Being the product of a quite specific situation in the Soviet social studies of the 1920s, since the 1970s – following the translations of some of his texts – it would become a part of the ‘Western’ (or ‘non-Soviet’) studies in value theory. The interest to Rubin’s contribution saw its ups and downs, the Rubin studies were unevenly disseminated across different countries and regions of the world, but on average he is widely recognized as one of the major Marxian scholars of the twentieth century Russia. To the contrary, in Russia after the early 1930s his approach was submerged and his very name erased from the official discourse. Even if there are evidences that his approach continued to exert an influence on some Soviet economists, this influence could not be revealed explicitly. Hence neither Rubin’s original approach, nor its alleged developments were the subjects to academic debates and scholarly criticism. Then, whatever influences there were, the crash of Soviet system (the Soviet economic science including) did a major blow to the continuity of the classical tradition (albeit in its rather peculiar Soviet form). Rubin’s approach was forbidden and quite forgotten during the major part of Soviet period, it is quite alien in the post-Soviet Russia. (This is not to say that the Rubin studies were altogether absent in Russia. In the late 1980s L. Vasina and Ya. Rokityansky initiated in fact the new wave of the Rubin studies based on the archival sources; two decades of Vasina’s meticulous work made possible the publication of Rubin’s last unpublished manuscript, Essays on Marx’s Theory of Money, in 2011: see the review of the Russian and the subsequent German editions in Takenaga 2013). Being adopted in various specific contexts outside of the country and the context of origin, Rubin’s approach became the subject of different reconstructions, with a risk that some important elements were lost in translation. To avoid the risk a careful reconstruction of his approach is needed. An essential element for this task is to consider Rubin’s approach within its original context. Rubin, among other scholars, tried to formulate sound answers to the challenges which the Marxian approach had faced since the end of the nineteenth century; he pursued that aim in the specific conditions of the post-revolutionary Russia. In the literature there are contributions to these matters (regarding the former see, e.g., Faccarello [1983]2016, regarding the latter – Takenaga 2016). But there is another important aspect. Rubin’s activity as a scholar lasted only about a decade, and even this short period was interrupted by several imprisonments and exile. Thus all his major contributions could be regarded as integral parts of a single research project – the project that arguably remained unfinished. However, up to the moment, not all his works have received equal scholarly attention. My paper is an attempt to consider Rubin’s works as a whole. Obviously this is quite demanding a task, and the paper is but a first approximation. References Faccarello G. ([1983] 2016) ‘La loi de la valeur et le problème de la coordination des activités économiques’, In: L'homme et la société, No. 67-68, pp. 153-177; translated into Russian and published in: I.I. Rubin: Political Economy and the Modernity, Moscow, Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences (forthcoming). Takenaga S. (2013) ‘Essays on Marx's theory of money’. In: The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 20(3), pp.536-542. Takenaga S. (2016) ‘Isaak Rubin and a Stage in the Debates on Value in the Soviet Union of the 1920s’, In: I.I. Rubin: Political Economy and the Modernity, Moscow, Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences (forthcoming).

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.