ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Shionoya's Concept of a Comprehensive Social Science: From Schumpeter to Economic Ontology
Author: Yagi Kiichiro


Shionoya's Concept of a Comprehensive Social Science: From Schumpeter to Economic Ontology Kiichiro Yagi (Setsunan University) In the late stage of his life, Shionoya extended his view of science toward the area of pre-theory and found his guide in the hermeneutics originating in Dilthey. He published Principles of Economic Philosophy: A Hermeneutical Approach (2009). Here, Shionoya advanced to the horizon of Heidegger's ontology, in which the peculiar nature of human being consists in our “thrownness” (Geworfenheit) in the world, with the inevitable quest for the meaning of our own existence. In this voyage, the embarkation port for Shionoya was Schumpeter's emphasis on “vision” as the precondition of scientific research. Schumpeter's concept of entrepreneurship was interpreted philosophically as a typical projection into the indeterminate future. The hermeneutical turn to pre-theory inspired Shionoya to integrate rhetoric and art into his purview. Located at the opposite pole from analysis, they represent the quest of the living totality to grasp human life. Shionoya's last book was The Economic Philosophy of Romanticism: Art, Ethics, and History (2012). It is interesting that we can find in the ideal elevation of being in Romanticism the quest for the quality of human being (virtue) in his early investigation into economic ethics. However, I cannot refrain from feeling anxiety against the tendency toward elitism in Shionoya's detour to virtue ethics via hermeneutics and Romanticism. In his first magnus opa, Structure of the Ideas of Value: Utility vs. Rights (1984), he appreciated Rawlesian social contract approach and argued its supremacy over utilitalianism by situating the conceptual social contract in the circle of reflective equilibrium. I would suggest that another route toward virtue ethics might be possible via the communicative turn of the social contract theory.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.