ABSTRACT OF PAPER

Title: Yuichi Shionoya on Joseph Schimpeter's Distinction between statics, dynamics and evolution
Author: Arena Richard


This very short contribution dedicated to the memory of Professor Shionoya in this round table focuses on his conception of economics as an open sscienceand is in line with his view of Joseph Schumpeter’s economic analysis. We all know indeed that to-day discussions are still going on with the purpose of opposing and comparing the merits of two different approaches to economic analysis. The first – the origin of which Schumpeter attributed to Léon Walras – consists to consider economics as a self-contained and closed discipline the autonomy of which is based on the theory General Economic Equilibrium and its form of modeling; according to this view autonomy is not a drawback but provides the very foundation of a real scientific approach. According to the second one economics has its originality as a discipline but is not self-contained; it is an open discipline which must be combined to other social sciences to provide a part of a ‘unitary social science’ according to Schumpeter’s expression. Now, this opposition is still present to-day when some debates on pluralism and inter-disciplinarity are taking place within the community of economists. Now, what I would like to argue here is that Yuichi Shionoya always defended an interpretation of Joseph Schumpeter’s contribution which favoured a conception of economics as an open science in spite of the great esteem the latter always expressed for Léon Walras. As Shionoya noted in a paper on ontology at the end of his life, “for Schumpeter the idea of evolution is identified not with economic development in isolation but with the processes of interrelated economic, political, social and institutional changes”. He also stressed the fact that evolution was not in Schumpeter a biological analogy but the result of a combination between economics and other social sciences especially history and economic sociology. This is why Shionoya shared Schumpeter’s interest for the concept of “universal social science” which combined a “system of substantive theory (economic statics, economic dynamics and economic sociology) and “a system of metatheory (philosophy of economics, history of economics and sociology of economics)”.

Registred web users only can download this paper - Go back


Please note that files available for download have not been checked for viruses. These files have been submitted by authors of the conference to this web site. Conference organisers can't accept any responsibility for damages caused to users by downloading such files.